I am facing my open locker, fumbling with my cleats. The guy to my right stands naked, face obscured by the blue metal door. I can sense the shape of him through my peripheral vision. But I have seen him many times. I know his shape. His size.
To my left, there is a row of urinals; around the corner, a rectangular, group shower. After games, my teammates lather their bodies and careen across the floor tiles like a slip-and-slide, prancing and showing off. They want to be seen. They want to be desired.
I was a closeted collegiate soccer player in the early 2000’s, at a Division III school called Trinity University. I had been the best player in my high school and had played on select teams. I was good enough to be on a good D-III college team (which won the NCAA championship my junior year), though I can’t say I was a prominent player.
Watching Heated Rivalry—yes, this is a post about that show—has reminded me of the person I was there, then, and the unrelenting homophobia, sometimes external, sometimes internal, of that moment. I was a closeted collegiate athlete in a time and place where there were no out athletes, and the show has reminded me not of how much shame I felt, but of how much I would have wanted to have been able to not feel so alone.
Before Trinity, I had been part of the Olympic Development Program, a system devised to help identify talented soccer players. I played on the South Texas select team for 3 years (Texas had 2 teams, North Texas and South Texas). We would meet during the summer to train, and every year we would also attend a week-long camp in Alabama, where the other state-level teams would meet and train and play each other—in hopes of being identified by higher level coaches and invited to the regional or national team.
I am 17 years old in a moldy dorm in Tuscaloosa, Alabama. A tall guy from West Africa is smiling as he walks down the hallway, naked, swinging his thick, languid dick. There is no reason for him to be naked, except to be seen. The exhibitionism of it all.
And there is a stuck up white guy from Austin, blue eyes and long eyelashes, talking about how many girls had given him blow jobs as he sits naked on his bed, touching himself.
I am crushed. My world implodes. I cannot breathe.
I remember sharing a dorm room with a guy named Stuart. We were talking and talking at night, about our future plans, about what we wanted to do in college, and I could not imagine not kissing him. But I could not fathom reaching out across the dark room to touch him either. I could feel the redness of my neck and could not admit it was desire.
At Trinity there were guys from all over the US and some international players. It was early morning training, and weigh ins, and weigh outs, sweating your ass off every day in the San Antonio heat, winning game after game. I played my part, getting faster, being more decisive, more direct, more technically sound. Fitter, smarter. I was a creative player, but sometimes lazy. I had vision, but could not always manage to pull off what I saw in my head.
In my freshman year, in our dorm, one of my teammates had a gay roommate. Or at least, he was rumored to be gay. The way they said it wasn’t hateful, more like intrigued. One night I found myself alone with him. Without talking, without convincing, he took my hand and led me to his car. It was as if he could see inside of me. And all of a sudden, I was in the back seat of a Lexus parked on the top level of the campus parking lot, kissing him, touching his chest, his face, his thighs.
It would take me three more years to come out.
I was playing soccer and closeted, and though I would swear otherwise, deep down, I knew it. I knew it in how I had to prevent my eyes from wandering. And in how I resented how the other guys flaunted their naked bodies in the locker room. I knew the shape of every body, every curve, whose was thick, thin, long, cut, uncut. We all did. That is the thing no one says out loud. We all knew.
Homoeroticism was inconceivable, and omnipresent. It was the thing that made their taunting and exhibitionism have meaning, it made their erotic play make sense.
The captain of the team would pull out his balls and show everyone how much skin he had, the bat-wing he called it. Others would join in. Not as big, not as much—he always won.
When I was watching Heated Rivalry, what I most understood, what I knew in my core, was the slow burn and the ecstatic encounter, the desire that cannot be contained or expressed, and how the crushing shame of that moment, that place, that homoeroticism, sticks to your pores, sticks to the roof of your mouth, lingers in the everyday impossibility of touching the body next to you.
What I knew as I watched was that this show delivers something unspeakable.
This isn’t so much about what the show is, but how it has made me remember myself.
I want to sit with the yearning. The knowing glances. The touching of feet. The smiles. The sweaty fucking. The perfect, glowing light on naked bodies in bed. The love that is impossible, and yet...
I could not have imagined acting on what I knew I wanted when I was in college. And perhaps, for me, that is where the show reaches into my past and reminds me of how drastically, dramatically, the display of homoeroticism was at that time, and yet, how impossible it was to pull back the curtain, to name what everyone was doing.
What I mean to say is that there is a sincerity in how the characters in this show (Ilya and Shane; Scott and Kip) fall inevitably in love, and that sincerity resonates with me as something I wanted, desperately, but could not name, could not articulate.
And sure, the plot of these romances relies heavily on melodramatic tropes—star crossed lovers, and the like—but like all melodramatic tropes, they reveal the codes and proscriptions of a society. And what happens, or what is promised in the show, is an upending of those codes, a rewriting of the shame and the impossible romance. It gives hope, I mean to say.
They are fulfilling the romantic fantasy that many gay men have had. My own fantasy. Perhaps the show pries open the moment (the repeating, unending moment) when I wanted to have been able to reach out, knowing full well that I would have been rejected. The show constructs the drive, the compulsion, almost the destiny, that these characters continue across the chasm between bodies. They touch.
And to me, that is where the show is magical. It shows not just what it is like to be a closeted athlete, but how much desire is actually required to push beyond the limits of queer shame.
I am tending to that memory, that shame, today. I am tending to the possibilities of my past self. I wanted to write this at the end of the year, not to leave it behind, but to care for that past, the complicated, unnerving past, and hope for its future. I don’t think my 20-year-old self could have imagined the life I am living now. The love I feel around me. And that is what, at least for me, the show offers. Not an endless cycle of repression, but the possibility of tending to the wounds of the past.































