
In the middle of May, the Advocate, a national LGBTQ magazine, published a rare headline about Seattle. âTransgender Americans are fleeing hostile red states,â it read. âSeattle says itâs overwhelmed.â
The headline was posted to social media, picked up by other queer outlets, and pingponged around the internet, latching onto readersâ confirmation biases on every side of the political spectrum. The story eventually bounced back to Seattle, where TV reporters parroted the Advocateâs headline: Seattle is overwhelmed by trans people!
Letâs state the obvious first: We are a city thatâs overwhelmed by many things. Our booming population? Sure. The tech sector? Maybe. High income earners inflating our cost of living? Most certainly. But our city of 800,000 people is not âoverwhelmedâ by trans people fleeing red states.
Unfortunately, that meme-able headline overshadowed what Seattleâs queer community was actually saying: The City isnât overwhelmed, but our queer community organizations are. Seattle is witnessing the beginning of an internally displaced refugee crisis. And itâs time for the city government to step in and live up to its claims that itâs a âWelcoming City,â and be one.
The story started with an article in Seattle Gay News on May 12. Seattleâs LGBTQ Commission had sent a letter to the Mayorâs Office, City Council, and City Attorneyâs Office, asking that they declare a civil emergency to address the increasing number of trans and queer people moving to Seattle from hostile states to escape anti-trans legislation, threats to personal safety, and a lack of health care and legal recognition.
Seattle is on a short list of US cities that are widely known to be especially safe for trans people. But moving here also means moving into one of the most expensive cities in the countyâundoubtedly more expensive than the city theyâre coming fromâin the midst of a housing and affordability crisis.
Jessa Davis, co-chair of the Seattle LGBTQ Commission, tells The Stranger that new arrivals are struggling to find work and housing. âWe have people who come here, and they sleep on a couch for two weeks, and then go to another couch for two weeks, and then maybe they have a car, maybe they choose to get a tent,â she says. âItâs really impossible to get the kind of money you need to rent a place on your own, and building a network fast enough where you can get a roommate or move in with someone long-term.â
There are no official (or even unofficial) numbers for how many trans people have moved here since the Trump administration poured fuel on the fire of the Repubican Partyâs anti-trans campaigns took off, but local organizations have consistently reported increased demand. âIn some cases, demand already exceeds available capacity,â the letter reads. And Seattleâs emergency response systems arenât built to help people who are displaced in their own country. So they felt it was necessary to declare a civil emergency.
A âcivil emergencyâ is largely a bureaucratic lever. Declaring one allows the mayor to throw money at a crisis without going through the time-consuming legislative process of allotting funds through City Council. And this wouldnât be the first time the Trump administration cornered us into it: Mayor Bruce Harrell declared a civil emergency when SNAP benefits went unfunded last year.
In this case, the commission hopes that declaring a civil emergency could allow the city to financially support the organizations that are already serving trans refugees in the city with housing, behavioral health, food access, legal services, and violence prevention.
A civil emergency isnât the only iron in the fire, and it might not be the best one. In the weeks before the commission sent the letter, City Councilmember Alexis Mercedes Rinck had already been working with community groups on an early draft of a Trans Bill of Rights that would âshape the cityâs approach to welcoming trans refugees.â She supported declaring a civil emergency when SNAP benefits were on the line, because there was a clear, single-step course of action ahead of them: Use emergency funds to fund the food banks. But in a nuanced situation like this refugee crisis, the demands on the executive branch arenât as clear. âA civil emergency only works when the executive knows what they want to do,â she says.
Davis stands by their letter. âItâs a short-term solution,â she says. âWe donât have money [for those services] in the budget today. But we have emergency funds, and we need to do something today⌠If we start by just talking about the future, then we are dooming the people between now and that future budget cycle to being entirely on their own in the face of potentially collapsing social support.â
After the swirl of the headlines settled, the mayor didnât declare an emergency. Instead, she announced a first step: an âinterdepartmental teamâ that will figure out what the executive wants to do. Theyâll work in âactive partnershipââwhatever that meansâwith the commission, community groups, and city council to recommend new legislation, including Rinckâs Trans Bill of Rights.
One of the Cityâs biggest challenges will be assessing just how many trans people have moved to Seattleâitâs hard to allocate resources when you donât know how many people need them. Rinck says sheâs been talking to the trans mutual aid groups like couch-surfing networks that have popped up all over the city, which have the most consistent, direct contact with trans people who have fled other states. Theyâre able to give her verbal estimates of the number of people theyâre working with, but many of them are informal and decentralized by nature. âI canât pull from a data system and say here are the exact numbers.â
Some of that is by design. âPeople are surviving by staying invisible,â says Rinck. Itâs true of anyone experiencing homelessness, she says, âbut thereâs a tremendous amount of danger that is facing trans people.â
The letter did commit to work on an âaccelerated timeline,â and they plan to finish in August. When it comes to funding, though, the letter committed to nothing. âAlthough our city is experiencing challenging budget constraints, we will proactively search for ways to meet urgent needs while planning for a stronger future,â Mayor Wilson wrote. But both Rinck and Davis have been heartened by the Cityâs quick responses so far. âIt surpassed my expectations,â Davis says. âItâs been met with a level of seriousness and engagement that Iâm frankly proud of.â
The post Seattle Is Not âOverwhelmedâ by Trans People appeared first on The Stranger.
